5 Actions That’ll Make Your Job Candidates Leave You
beafields I was talking with a young woman last week about her last job interview. Here’s a recap of what happened.
1) She interviewed for a job in June
2) The company told her they wanted her, and they wanted her to start July 22 or the week of. They told her they would call her to confirm the actual start date
3) The July 22 date came…no call.
4) The young woman called the company on July 23 to inquire about the situation. She has not yet received a call back from the company.
In my opinion, this is by far the rudest, most inconsiderate action on behalf of the company. What this company does not know is that she is now talking to people like me about the situation. I am not going to blog about who the company is, but I can assure you of this: If I hear of anyone who is considering employment with this company, I will quickly inform them that they need to run as far away from them as they can.
So, here are the 5 actions that you must avoid…if you don’t, great job candidates will leave you, AND they will probably blog and tweet about it, letting millions of people know that your company stinks.
1) Making promises you cannot deliver.
This is the oldest rule in business…Under-promise and over-deliver. If you have any doubt in your mind that a candidate is not going to be a good fit for your company, do not make any promises you cannot keep.
2) Not returning a phone call.
Please…I don’t even need to go into this one. This is just ridiculous. This young woman should have received a call back on July 1 letting her know that she was not selected or that the date/plan had changed.
3) Having a “loose” recruitment process.
Your job candidates should know the process upfront. I recommend that you have the following:
Please, please…spell out this process on your website and in any hiring literature you publish.
1. A resume screening process. Make sure your candidate has the required skills before you even contact them. If after reviewing a resume, this candidate is not a good fit, go ahead and thank them so much for applying but the skills of a, b, c are required and you do need someone with those skills.
2. If the resume passes the first test, schedule a phone interview. If during the phone interview, you are certain the candidate is not going to be a great fit, meet with your interview team, make the decision and then telephone the candidate and let her know. This gives the candidate the time to move on to the next interview without wondering if she is in the running for the job.
3. Schedule 3 interviews, and let your candidates know that you will inform them if they are moving on to the next round…and let them know as soon as possible (preferably within 48 hours.)
4. At each step of the process, if you are “cutting” someone, call them, let them know how much you appreciate them coming for the interview but that you are looking for someone with the x, y, z skills.
5. At the end of the interview process, send a very nice letter to your candidates thanking them profusely for considering your company. Encourage them to build out their skills and come back again in the future.
4) Sending a “Dear John” letter by e-mail.
Our world has become so impersonal. Our high tech world has become so messy that candidates are saying they are hearing “no” by a form letter by e-mail and even a text. This is ridiculous. If you don’t have the staff on hand to actually telephone the individual to let them know that he/she is not moving on to the next round, then you should not be holding open interviews. You should be recruiting from inside your company or inside a small closed network but not opening up your recruitment process to the world.
5) Being cold/insensitive during the rejection process.
Again…the “sorry…you didn’t make it” approach is just infuriating to me. The candidate needs to be called, thanked for their time, praised for the skills they do offer and then told why they were not hired. Give the candidate time to ask questions and offer feedback (but only if they ask for it.) If a candidate wants to know more about why they were not hired, speak this in the positive and make it about the skills they need to improve…whether it be their communication skills, their tech skills, foreign language skills, etc. But, make this closing off process as empathetic as possible
Our young employees are going to be key to our success in the future, and they do want and appreciate feedback. They WANT to know why they weren’t hired or what they can do better. If your company is not “big enough” to have the tough yet compassionate conversation at the end, in my opinion, you won’t be around in the future. Customer service is not just about how you treat your paying customers…it is about how you treat your employees AND your potential employees. So…it’s time to get with it! Remember…you are dealing with human beings…not robots or a piece of software.
Posted in Interviews, Uncategorized |
No Comments »




